
Is Jason Marshall Jr. the Dolphins’ Secret Weapon for a Turnaround Defense?
The Miami Dolphins have made a strategic move in the 2025 NFL Draft, selecting Florida cornerback Jason Marshall Jr. in the fifth round. As the team grapples with uncertainties in their secondary, this pick raises intriguing questions about whether Marshall can bolster a defense that's been under scrutiny. With the Dolphins eyeing improvements amid potential trades and roster shake-ups, this draft choice could be a pivotal step in reshaping their lineup—or just another piece in a complex puzzle.
In a draft filled with high-stakes decisions, the Dolphins opted for Marshall with the 155th overall pick, acquired from the Denver Broncos as part of the 2022 trade for Bradley Chubb. This selection comes at a time when the team's cornerback room is in flux, especially after General Manager Chris Grier confirmed discussions to explore trading seven-time Pro Bowl star Jalen Ramsey. Without Ramsey, the Dolphins are left with a mix of young talents like Storm Duck, Ethan Bonner, and second-round pick Cam Smith, alongside veterans like Artie Burns and potential free agent signings such as Rasul Douglas or Stephon Gilmore.
Marshall, a 6-foot, 194-pound Miami native, brings a blend of experience and athleticism to the table. Over four seasons at the University of Florida, he started at least seven games each year, amassing two interceptions and leading the Gators with 10 pass breakups in 2023. However, his 2023 season was cut short by a shoulder injury after just seven games, where he also recorded three tackles for loss and a sack. NFL.com draft analyst Lance Zierlein offered a candid assessment, describing Marshall as an 'average backup or special-teamer' with strengths in zone coverage but notable weaknesses in press situations and tackling. Zierlein noted, 'He falls asleep against play-action and misdirection... For his size, he’s a disappointing tackler, especially in run support.'

Comparisons to Denver Broncos' Damarri Mathis from Bleacher Report's scouting report highlight Marshall's potential as a depth player in zone-heavy schemes. He excels in route recognition and leverage, with solid speed to prevent deep threats, but struggles against physical receivers and in run support. As a two-time SEC Academic Honor Roll member and a five-star recruit in 2021, Marshall's intangibles add to his appeal, though his hip tightness and inconsistent tape could limit his immediate impact. The Dolphins might view him as competition for spots on the roster, potentially supplementing with veteran free agents to address gaps.
This pick reflects a broader trend in the Dolphins' draft strategy: building depth with promising but unpolished talents. While some analysts graded it a 'C,' citing Marshall's inconsistencies, others see it as a low-risk move for a team needing options. If Marshall can refine his skills, he might emerge as a key contributor; otherwise, he risks becoming just another developmental project in a crowded room.
Ultimately, the Dolphins' selection of Jason Marshall Jr. underscores the high stakes of NFL team-building in 2025. As the league evolves with faster offenses and dynamic playmakers, will this pick help Miami reclaim defensive dominance? It's a question that could define their upcoming season and beyond.
In summary, this draft choice highlights the Dolphins' efforts to fortify their defense amid uncertainties, offering a mix of potential and challenges. What do you think—could Marshall be the spark the team needs? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let us know if you're excited about this addition or skeptical of its impact. Don't forget to like, share, and follow for more NFL updates!