9th Circuit Upholds California’s Ban on Large-Capacity Ammunition Magazines Amid Controversial Judicial Dissent

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld California's ban on large-capacity ammunition magazines, marking a significant victory for gun control advocates. The decision, which affirms a lower court ruling, prohibits the possession of magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds, a measure aimed at reducing gun violence across the state.

In a unique turn of events, Judge Roger T. Benitez, a Trump appointee who dissented from the ruling, took to YouTube to express his disagreement. In a video titled 'The Truth about Gun Handling,' Benitez demonstrated how to use firearms, a move seen by many as a direct critique of the court's decision. His actions have sparked a debate on judicial ethics and the role of social media in legal discourse.

Adding to the controversy, Judge Benitez's video comes in the wake of a recent incident involving Judge Timothy Van Dyke, who was filmed handling guns in a similar context, raising questions about the appropriateness of such actions by judicial figures.

The ruling and subsequent judicial reactions highlight the ongoing tension between gun rights and gun control in the United States, a debate that continues to polarize communities and influence policy at both state and federal levels.

• 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
• California
• Roger T. Benitez
• Timothy Van Dyke

Detailed News about California • Ninth Circuit • gun magazines

9th Circuit upholds California ban on large-capacity ammunition magazines

2 weeks ago

- latimes

Gun-Handling Judge Posts a Novel YouTube Dissent in Second Amendment Case

2 weeks ago

- wsj

California appeals court upholds ban on higher-capacity magazines, spurring unusual video dissent

2 weeks ago

- abcnews

Trump-appointed judge records gun tutorial to slam court ruling

2 weeks ago

- reuters

9th Circuit judge handles a cache of firearms while robed in bizarre video dissent

2 weeks ago

- sfchronicle