Fans Spark Debate Over Whether 90 Day Fiance Star Lives in Iconic Modern Family House
Speculation has swirled among reality TV fans as sharp-eyed viewers of "90 Day Fiancé" season 11 believe they might have spotted star Shawn Finch residing in none other than the famous sitcom house from ABC’s “Modern Family.” While the theory ultimately proves untrue, the intriguing debate illustrates the intersection of Hollywood’s TV history with the glossy world of reality stars—and the deep devotion of passionate fans who scrutinize every frame.
The frenzy began after a viewer on Reddit compared Shawn’s West Hollywood residence, featured prominently this season, to the instantly recognizable home belonging to TV couple Mitch and Cam on "Modern Family." "[Do] Shawn and Allyah live in the Modern Family house?! When Shawn walked in I recognized that doorway," the post read, alongside photos matching interior shots and the sitcom couple—played by Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Eric Stonestreet—posing outside the set’s exterior. Replies flooded in, with one fan saying, "Wow, it definitely looks like it," while another chimed in, "That was my first thought too."
However, some skeptics quickly pointed out that many Los Angeles homes share similar styles. As one commenter noted, “There are a lot of houses like this in LA.” Ultimately, their doubts were justified. The famous "Modern Family" house is actually located at 2213 Fox Hills Drive in LA’s Century City district, a popular stop for sitcom devotees and tourists alike. By contrast, Shawn’s house is situated on Clark Street in West Hollywood—and is even currently up for rent reportedly at $7,995 per month on the site Dwellsy.
While the dream of a crossover between two beloved TV worlds has been debunked, it’s not hard to see why fans found the idea compelling. Shawn himself is no stranger to Hollywood icons—he is known as a celebrity hairstylist with a vast collection of memorabilia, including stage costumes once worn by Barbra Streisand. This flair for glamorous nostalgia permeates his lifestyle and has been a recurring theme throughout his appearances on the show.
Speaking of memorable decor, the official “90 Day Fiancé” Instagram recently showcased Shawn’s fiancée, Alliya de Batista, as she explored Shawn’s home filled with striking (sometimes whimsical) collectibles. Standing amidst shelves crowded with dinosaur figurines, Alliya quipped, "They are everywhere. It’s really the ‘Jurassic Park’ world." The lighthearted moment reflects the couple’s dynamic, which has captivated viewers both for their humor and their meaningful journey.
Fans first met Shawn and Alliya in the 2024 season of "90 Day Fiancé: Love in Paradise." In earlier episodes, Shawn movingly spoke about their evolving relationship, sharing, "I picked Douglas, I didn’t pick Alliya," referencing his partner’s transition after they met—a narrative that has resonated deeply in the fan community as the couple navigates love and major life changes together on a national stage.
Despite the house mystery being laid to rest, this story exemplifies the enthusiasm of audiences who piece together Hollywood connections, speculate about behind-the-scenes details, and root for real-life love stories. Whether or not the house has sitcom roots, Shawn and Alliya continue to forge a unique space in reality TV—one that merges heartfelt storytelling with a touch of Hollywood magic.
What do you think—could another TV crossover be hiding in plain sight, or was this simply a case of mistaken identity? Share your thoughts and join the conversation below!